Entertainment Weekly’s Bullshit List, #75-71.
Wednesday, October 1st, 2008
75. Bruce Springsteen, Born In The U.S.A.
JB: Nobody thinks that Born In The U.S.A. is the Boss’s greatest album, except perhaps for those benighted souls who believe that sales are correlative to quality (and let’s leave them alone; surely being that ignorant is suffering enough). The problem is, I don’t think he’s had a really great record since Nebraska. (I like the Seeger Sessions a lot, and he’s continued to write great songs even at his lowest ebbs. But cohesive albums? That’s just not what he does anymore.)
I know the standard narrative around this record: after the massively popular Born To Run was followed by the various crises (of confidence, of commerce, of conscience) represented by Darkness On The Edge Of Town, The River, and Nebraska, Springsteen roared back into relevance, into the charts, and into the hearts of Americans everywhere with this expansive, shiny, bombastic record about the American mood circa the end of Reagan’s first term.
But that narrative has worn a little thin in the twenty-plus years since, and as someone who Wasn’t There™, what strikes me most immediately about the record is how small it is. Which may sound counterintuitive; surely there are few huger 80s productions than the title track, few records which have seized the (or, rather a) zeitgeist of 1984 with such all-conquering aplomb, with indeed such force that Springsteen more or less defined what commercial rootsy rock would sound like for — well, for the rest of rock’s life. From now on, no American rocker who wanted to be taken seriously by his aging audience would sound unlike Springsteen. (Of course that leaves out metal- and punk-influenced rock musics, which could fairly be said to have won if the game were anything but winning Boomer approval.)