
Yes, Close To The Edge
File Between: Mahavishnu Orchestra and Led Zeppelin
Comments: I wouldn’t consider myself a fan of Yes, but every time I listen to a Yes record I have to ask myself why I’m not. Then Jon Anderson starts singing and I say, “oh yeah, that’s why.” Unlike the typical progressive rock band, they’re not limited to the Western canon from Bach to Chuck Berry — they have serious elements of funk, fusion jazz, Middle Eastern music, and avant-garde sonics of the kind Brian Eno would make his name exploring in the rest of the decade. Squire, Bruford, and Howe are among the most forward-thinking instrumentalists of their day. Then Anderson comes in with his dippy sci-fi lyrics and helium vocals, and I have to wait for another fine instrumental passage. But then, too, whenever Rick Wakeman dominates, the whole thing tends to comes crashing to a deathly boring halt — although his supremely dull organ solo on the side-long title track is followed by a whiz-bang showcase once the rest of the band comes back in. It’s one of the better side-long tracks of the era (and yes, I have listened to quite a few; a formal study was cut short by the death of my iPod). The second side is less invigorating: the ten-minute “And You And I” is as goopy as its title sounds (though their rhythmic sense is still strong even in an acoustic ballad), and the nine-minute “Siberian Khatru” is too many good ideas stuffed in with a too many dodgy ones (a harpsichord solo right after the sitar solo?), but it’s pretty great funk-rock in several sections.
A Keeper? It’s not my favorite Yes album, but then Yes never made an album I’ve loved all the way through. Maybe Tales From Topographic Oceans. Maybe.
Vinyl Rip: Siberian Khatru