1972 Case File #51.
Friday, November 28th, 2008
The Four Tops, Keeper Of The Castle
File Between: Marvin Gaye and The O’Jays
Comments: Several of Motown’s signature Sixties acts had been set loose by this point, and were finding other homes less monolithically insistent on chart material. The Four Tops released this record (one of two they made this year) on Dunhill, a subsidiary of ABC, which might indicate a move towards easy listening (or “adult contemporary,” in later trade lingo), but which sounds more or less just like Philly-lite. It’s not just a hit machine, either: the one hit from the record, “Ain’t No Woman (Like The One I’ve Got)” isn’t necessarily a stronger cut than several others. The late Levi Stubbs is in fine form here, though he doesn’t have anything as meaty as a Holland-Dozier-Holland song to sink his teeth into (or as worthy a soundscaping as the Funk Brothers with Norman Whitfield on the knobs), in some ways his performances come through more clearly and righteously when the rest of the elements are so thin. And he’s not the only singer in the place: although when someone else takes a lead, it only points out how great Stubbs is. The songs gesture towards social commentary and up-with-people philosophizing, and the production toys with futurism, without ever losing sight of the Four Tops’ primary mandate of making music by which to get it on.
A Keeper? It’s merely as okay a record as the sleeve’s half-assed commercial-illustration artwork would seem to predict, but the Four Tops never made a bad record.
Vinyl Rip: Turn On The Light Of Your Love